Difference between revisions of "20.109(S22):M3D2"

From Course Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(Created page with "<div style="padding: 10px; width: 820px; border: 5px solid #434a43;"> {{Template:20.109(S22)}} ==Exercises== ===Part 1: Draft aims for Research proposal presentation=== ...")
 
(Exercises)
Line 22: Line 22:
 
*Draft the objectives that will be used to accomplish each aim.
 
*Draft the objectives that will be used to accomplish each aim.
  
===Part 3: Consider the societal implications of Research proposal===
+
===Part 2: Brainstorm alternative approaches for Research proposal experiments===
  
Thus far we have focused on the problem that you are addressing as part of the Research proposal presentation; however, another important aspect of this assignment is defining the societal impacts of your proposed workIn recent years, funding agencies have placed increased emphasis on societal impact when reviewing grant applications and the public has been more critical of the use of government funds toward research that does not benefit the populationThis sentiment is expressed in a recently published editorial:
+
Another important part of the Research proposal presentation is the inclusion of alternative approachesBecause experiments do not always produce the expected results, or even interpretable results, researchers often need to develop new plans to accomplish a scientific goalIn this exercise you will work with your co-investigator to consider alternative approaches for your Research proposal.
 
+
''"...research funding agencies will no longer be satisfied with claims that our research has impact merely because we use it in training of our students, because it is well-cited by other academics, or because it is published in reputable journals...it seems reasonable that at least some discernible societal value should emerge from research."'' (Davison and Bjorn-Anderson. ''Info Systems J.'' 2019;29:989-993)
+
 
+
Read and discuss the following perspective with your co-investigator:
+
 
+
Frodeman and Holbrook. "[http://issues.org/p_frodeman-3/#.Xxyp0cFzn3A.link Science's social effects.]" ''Issues in Science and Technology''. Vol. XXIII, No. 3, Spring 2007.
+
  
 
'''Questions to guide your discussion:'''
 
'''Questions to guide your discussion:'''
#What are the societal implications of your proposed research?
+
#How might you 'double-check' or confirm an expected result?
#*Which populations benefit from your researchIs it possible any populations will be negatively impacted by your research?
+
#What if you do not get the expected result?
#*Will cost limitations impede / bias which populations are benefited?
+
#What can be learned if you get the expected resultIf you get an unexpected result?
#*Is your research applicable to all populations?
+
#What are some alternative approaches (methods) for your proposed research?
#What are the ethical implications of your proposed research?
+
  
 
<font color =  #4a9152 >'''In your laboratory notebook,'''</font color> complete the following:
 
<font color =  #4a9152 >'''In your laboratory notebook,'''</font color> complete the following:

Revision as of 13:29, 13 January 2022

20.109(S22): Laboratory Fundamentals of Biological Engineering

Sp17 20.109 M1D7 chemical structure features.png

Spring 2022 schedule        FYI        Assignments        Homework        Class data        Communication        Accessibility

       M1: Drug discovery        M2: Metabolic engineering        M3: Project design       


Exercises

Part 1: Draft aims for Research proposal presentation

Now that you have a research question / goal, what experimental steps will you use to get your answer? The approaches that you include in your Research proposal presentation should be divided into aims and objectives.

Aims: are broad statements that provide the intended outcome for each major step in your proposal. The purpose is to tell the audience what you will accomplish without the details of how. For each aim, there should be a list of specific objectives that detail how you will achieve the aim.

Objectives: are the steps that you will use to accomplish your aim. The purpose is to tell the audience the details regarding how you will accomplish the aim. For each objective, there should be a specific method that achieves the objective.

For your Research proposal presentation, you will present 2-3 aims that address your research question / goal. To get you started on this task you will work with your co-investigator to draft the aims and objectives for your project in class.

Hint: you can find the information provided during the Comm Lab workshop on the Communication page for help!

In your laboratory notebook, complete the following:

  • Write 2-3 aims for your research project.
  • Draft the objectives that will be used to accomplish each aim.

Part 2: Brainstorm alternative approaches for Research proposal experiments

Another important part of the Research proposal presentation is the inclusion of alternative approaches. Because experiments do not always produce the expected results, or even interpretable results, researchers often need to develop new plans to accomplish a scientific goal. In this exercise you will work with your co-investigator to consider alternative approaches for your Research proposal.

Questions to guide your discussion:

  1. How might you 'double-check' or confirm an expected result?
  2. What if you do not get the expected result?
  3. What can be learned if you get the expected result? If you get an unexpected result?
  4. What are some alternative approaches (methods) for your proposed research?

In your laboratory notebook, complete the following:

  • Based on your discussion with your co-investigator, answer the questions above.
==Navigation links==